Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Sorry to be so meta, but what on earth was the point of extracting programmers.stackexchange.com from stackoverflow.com? Is this why so many questions get closed as being "off topic" on stackoverflow now? </rant>


The original idea was to make it a bit of a waste bin for all the softer questions which had relevance to programmers but weren't directly related to programming. Remember the SO model takes a pretty hard line on what's relevant to try and minimise the noise and this was seen as a solution to what to do with questions which were interesting and semi-relevant but seemed too much like noise to many.

After while Programmers was becoming a bit too much of a dumping ground so tightened up the rules to make it less random and chatty and more of a valid site in it's own right for topics around software development but which are not directly programming related.


Whenever I use Programmers, all my questions get closed there.


me too :(


I believe the guidelines divide the two as objective vs. subjective.

Stackoverflow (Objective): Why does this code give me a syntax error?

Programmers (Subjective): What programming methodology best fits my project and team?


> What programming methodology best fits my project and team?

A question like this tends to elicit a much more forceful response on P.SE than it will on Stack Overflow. Largely because the folks who moderate P.SE aren't terribly fond of the common perception that their site is just a dumping ground for questions that are too wishy-washy for SO.


Usually subjective questions are now closed as "not constructive".


Looking at their current faq, it seems that they've better defined (and perhaps somewhat re-defined) what is to be asked there. Understandable as I stopped browsing the site because the questions got annoying. Compare the old faq: http://web.archive.org/web/20100912194040/http://programmers...


Programmers is for things related to the profession and trade of programming, and is more people- and politics-oriented (e.g. how do I get a raise?)

Stackoverflow is for stuff strictly about code, APIs, languages, syntax, etc.


And the confusing thing is that this question would seem to fall into the latter bucket.


It's the Wikia play on becoming the QA for specific things.

Quora couldn't grow because they wanted to become THE site, SO is smart enough to pander to niches.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: